On Your Tail: All Mysteries Guide

Mysteries are the main storyline for the game; as such, seeking out and completing them will reward the player with new areas to visit and additional character interactions. Diana collects clues for each mystery either by talking to other characters or by using her Chronolens to find clues in the area. The only two mystery games which do not require any clues are the final two. Once enough clues have been gathered, the deduction phase begins.

The overall appearance of the mystery solving game is that of a board game, with characters represented as pawns and actions represented by playing cards. Some levels have gimmicks unique to them, but the overall goal is the same: use the right combination of cards in the right order to reveal what happened at a crime scene. From “Accuse the Major” onward, two cards can be used in combination to form one new card. There will also be goals for each mystery shown at the top left at all times, which will be checked off so long as the player uses the right cards.

The results screen, whether the player wins or loses, will display the cards the player used and the order in which they played them. Correct cards are highlighted in green, making it easier to discern what the correct combination is through process of elimination.

In this guide, I will be sharing the correct combination of cards to solve each mystery. Due to the nature of this, spoilers for the game’s various twists are inevitable. You have been warned!

Description: This girl has lost her car keys. They can’t be far away!

1. Items on the Hood
2. Map on Tree

Description: Orlando’s villa was robbed tonight! Maybe I can give him a hand and find out who did it.

1. Books on the Ground
2. Messy Drawers
3. Open Chest
4. Chea’s Prototype

Description: Mama Lucia’s place has been turned upside down, but nothing important seems to have been stolen. We’d best make sure about that…

1. Telephone Call
2. Messy Cupboard
3. Chair out of Place
4. Hat on the Ground

Description: The thief managed to escape Mama Lucia’s place without being seen, but how?

1. Broken Branches
2. Thunderstorm
3. Telephone Call
4. Robbery at the Trattoria
5. Comforting Talk
6. Missing Boat

Description: I need to find a place to stay for at least one more night at Borgo Marina! Sleeping on the beach is as romantic as it is uncomfortable.

1. Yearning for Company
2. A Restaurant Downstairs
3. Learning to Fish
4. The Church is Noisy

Description: Did Gordon really shoot Menettu? There’s only one way to find out!

1. Scolding Giovanna
2. Giovanna on the Rocks (Giovanna + Tracks in Sand)
3. Children Sent Out
4. Paun Runs on the Walkway (Chasing Photo + Rope)
5. Time Flies
6. Life Ring Thrown

Description: The statue created by Adriano and Cecilia was ruthlessly vandalized. Let’s try to reconstruct the facts and unmask the culprit!

1. Medeu’s Arrival
2. Paun’s Arrival
3. Time Passes…
4. Chea’s Arrival
5. Time Passes…
6. Cecilia’s Arrival

Description: I suspect some poked around in Adriano’s cellar. The only way to know for sure is… to poke around myself!

1. Empty Bottle
2. Paint Bucket
3. Moved Carpet
4. Paint Bucket
5. Empty Bottle
6. Moved Carpet
7. Empty Bottle
8. Skirt Piece

Description: Gordon, Racilio, Orlando and Mayor Malagamba were attacked at church! Santa Madre, what happened in there?

1. Hid Behind the Pulpit (Hidden + Pulpit)
2. Pushed into Vase (Push + Vase)
3. Jumped Behind the Altar (Hidden + Altar)
4. Pushed into the Candelabra (Push + Candle Stick)
5. Pushed into the Bench (Push + Bench)
6. Hid Behind the Door (Hidden + Closed Doors

Description: One night, a terrible fire consumed an villa outside of the town. Despite everything, it is now a cold case waiting to be reopened.

1. Someone Arrived with a Suitcase
2. Luggage Outside the House
3. Abandoned Car
4. Fire at the Villa
5. Tracks Under the Porch

Description: Lexua was there on the night of the fire at the villa. The Borgo Marina tragedy conceals more mysteries than we thought.

1. The Fire Started in the Dining Room
2. Suitcase on the Stairs
3. Lexua is Hit (Lexua’s Scar + Fire Poker)
4. Moira Flips the Cabinet Over (Cabinet + Golf Club)
5. Gustavo Grabs his Money (Fire Poker + Safe)
6. Fallen Beam

Description: The Guniglis were robbed, and I’m stuck in the middle of it all! I need to remedy this situation right away.

1. Medeu enters, then Gemma, then Lumin last.
2. Changed Alarm Clock
3. Running Down the Stairs
4. The Cuniglis’s Closed Windows
5. Theft
6. Shadow on the Roof
7. Unmade Bed
8. Open Closet Door

Description: The night on which the fire broke out at Villa Fidato, a girl vanished into thin air, without leaving a trace.

1. Paun’s Cone + Mint Gelato
2. Menettu Devours Gelatos
3. Menettu Devours Gelatos
4. Lexua’s Cone + Chocolate Gelato
5. Menettu Devours Gelatos
6. Fisherman + Special Gelato
7. Lucia’s Cone + Mint Gelato
8. Cone for the Child
9. Chea’s Cone + Chocolate Gelato
10. Lucia’s Children’s Cone + Chocolate Gelato

Description: It’s time to make this silly thief see how stubborn an academic from Turin can be. Bring it on!

1. At the Entrance to the Bell Tower
2. Middle of the Piazza
3. To the Bench
4. At the Foot of the Stairs
5. To the Bulletin Board
6. At the Entrance to the Church
7. Under the Wall

Description: If we don’t act now, Borgo Marina will be destroyed. It will be the end for all of us!

1. I Move to the Side (Diana + Move to Center)
2. Paun Uses His Grappling Hook
3. Go back to the center (Diana + Move to Center)
4. Paun Warns Diana
5. Diana Encourages Paun
6. To the Center, Now! (Both + Move to Center)